Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Cape Coral, FL & compare the best quotes from them.
| Home Insurance Company | A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating | Homeowners Insurance Market share |
|---|---|---|
| Nationwide | A+ | 8.2% |
| Erie | A+ | 7.02% |
| State Farm | A | 6.9% |
| Liberty Mutual | A | 3.2% |
| Travelers | A++ | 3.1% |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jason Stefely | 389 COMMERCIAL CT STE C www.jasoninsures.com 34292 |
941-244-2683 | |
| Todd Hufstetler | 3401 Bonita Beach Rd www.toddhufstetler.com 34134 |
||
| Jason Stefely | 2100 S TAMIAMI TRL www.jasoninsures.com 34293 |
800-891-4222 | |
| Steve Candon | 7650 San Sebastian Way www.stevecandon.com 34109 |
||
| Donna Young | 13650 Fiddlstiks Blvd Ste 203 www.donnayoungagency.com 33912 |
(239) 561-8600 | |
| Dwight Lewis | 1542 Carson St www.dwightglewis.com 33901 |
(239) 344-7414 | |
| Mike Esposito | 1865 Tamiami Trail S 34293 |
(941) 882-5768 | |
| Dan Gassner | 21 S Indiana Avenue www.dangassner.com 34223-3305 |
941-474-9591 | |
| Valerie Davis-Bailey | 4091 Colonial Blvd Fort\u00a0Myers www.valeriedavisbailey.com 33966 |
||
| Lindsey Patto | 7370 COLLEGE PKWY STE 312 www.lindseypattoinsurance.com 33907 |
239-275-3888 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Insurance Plus Corporation | 601 DEL PRADO BLVD N STE 11 33909 |
239-772-1287 | |
| Emerald Insurance Services Inc | 395 Commercial Ct Ste A 34292 |
(941) 485-2447 | |
| Westhill Risk Mgmt Corp | 24241 S Tamiami Trl Ste 1 www.westhillfinancial.com 34134 |
||
| Midlothian Insurance Agency | 4100 Goodlette Rd N www.midlothianinsurance.com 34103 |
(239) 261-3646 Email:rgreenlee@midlothianinsurance.com |
|
| Total Insurance Agency Group | 1395 Panther Lane St 100 34109 |
||
| Taylor Agency | 17595 S Tamiami Trail #204 Ft.\u00a0Myers 33908 |
||
| Tripple Tripple & Tripple Llc | 6640 Taylor Rd #111 33950 |
||
| Connerton - Feran & Associates | 1450 Airport Pulling Road N www.connerton-feran.com 34104-3351 |
239-261-6665 | |
| Cannady & Warner Insurance Agency Inc | 14904 Tamiami Trl 34287-2717 |
941-426-2990 | |
| Fred Buchholz Insurance | 240 S Bridge 33975 |
(863) 675-2411 Email:fredbuchholzinsurance@yahoo.com |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lindsay Curtis Lutcf | 2804 DEL PRADO BLVD #201 33904 |
239-549-8001 | |
| Jason Tansey | 270 S TAMIAMI TRAIL 34285 |
941-493-1583 | |
| Lindsay Berkey | 3501 DEL PRADO BLVD S STE 204 33904 |
239-542-1533 | |
| Lindsey Lane | 1537 BRANTLEY RD BLDG C 33907 |
239-437-5555 | |
| Crystal Rios | 2269 Tamiami Trail S 34293-5067 |
941-497-4422 | |
| Eliesha Cavanaugh | 21202 Olean Blvd Ste E3 33952 |
(941) 627-9222 | |
| Jacob Bosch | 24830 BURNT PINE DR STE 2 34134 |
239-481-1466 | |
| Thomas Caraceni Lutcf | 3900 Cleveland Ave Ft.\u00a0Myers 33901 |
||
| Lindsay Stifflemire | 13 NICHOLAS PKWY W #A 33991 |
239-458-7468 | |
| Jason Sardi | 992 TAMIAMI TRAIL UNIT E2 33953 |
941-889-7836 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jason Scott Thomas | 4212 N ACCESS RD SUITE A 34224 |
941-474-8431 | |
| Nationwide Sales Solutions Inc | 1421 PINE RIDGE RD STE 200 34109 |
(239) 262-5143 | |
| Thomas E. Forbes | 395 Commercial Ct Ste C 34292 |
||
| Denise Sullivan Clement Agency | 1807 Englewood Rd 34223 |
(941) 475-7778 | |
| Teddy J Byrd Agency | 555 E Ave 34285 |
||
| Stanley Wayne Bullen Jr Agency | 12331 Towne Lake Dr Ste 1 33913 |
||
| Ds Sherwood & Assoc Ins & Fin Svcs | 2425 Tamiami Trl N Ste 212 34103 |
(239) 261-6533 | |
| Holly Mcmillin Agency | 6609 WILLOW PARK DR STE 201 34109 |
239-261-6116 | |
| Michael P Manci Agency | 9390 Dynasty Drive Suite 105 33905 |
1-239-277-5122 | |
| Dennis Charles Oneill | 21554 Angela Ln 34293 |
(941) 493-5808 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Springer - Springer Insurance | 4735 Santa Barbara Dr Unit 8 34104 |
||
| Lindquist Insurance Associates Inc. | 1103 CAPE CORAL PKWY EAST SUITE A 33904 |
239-549-6255 | |
| The Wes Connor Agency | 728 Sw Pine Island Rd #16 Cape\u00a0Coral www.wesconnor.com 33991 |
(239) 800-9869 | |
| Blue Grass Insurance Bowling Green | 27241 Bay Landing Dr Ste 3 https 34135 |
(239) 947-4333 | |
| Spathies Insurance Agency Inc. | 12660 World Plaza Ln Ft.\u00a0Myers 33907 |
||
| Short Pump Insurance Llc | 230 Tamiami Trl S Ste 31 34285 |
||
| The Young Group Of Fuquay | 41180 Horseshoe Rd www.tygof.com 33982 |
||
| Brockey Insurance Agency | 12995 S Clevlnd Ave Ste 103B www.brockeyinsurance.com 33907-3859 |
239-561-8599 | |
| Earle Insurance Agency | 2481 Del Prado Blvd N Ste 117 33909 |
(239) 540-4848 | |
| Strachan Insurance Agency Inc. | 421 A Commercial Court 34292 |
| State Farm | Nationwide | Erie | |
| Median Home Value ($) | 171,900 | 171,900 | 191,900 |
| Construction year | 1999 | 2013 | 1984 |
| Home Coverage ($) | $175000-$200000 | $150000-$175000 | $100000-$125000 |
| Total Premium ($) | $2956 | $2210 | $2197 |
| Home Insurance Company | Multi Policy Discount (%) |
|---|---|
| Travelers | upto 11% |
| Liberty Mutual | upto 16% |
| Nationwide | upto 5% |
| Erie | upto 17% |