Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Highlands County, FL & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Highlands County, FL

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
Erie A+ 7.02%
State Farm A 6.9%
Allstate A+ 4.9%
Liberty Mutual A 3.2%
Travelers A++ 3.1%

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Highlands County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Larry Gaskill 146 E Stuart Ave
33853
Steve Ulmer 1906 S Parrott Ave
www.steveulmer.com 34974
Garrett Seawright 309 Us Highway 27 S
www.garrettseawright.com 33852
(863) 465-7155
Dan Flattery 23865 US Hwy 27 N
www.danflattery.com 33859
863-676-6633
Michelle Yates 4101 Us 27 N
33870
(863) 382-3131
Eddie Sandoval 1010 W Main St
www.sfsandoval.com 33825
(863) 452-6822
Georgann Hoffman 1802 S Parrott Ave
www.georgannhoffman.com 34974
(863) 763-7711
Jim Stoltz 309 U S Hwy 27 S
33852
Tim Wagner 1925 E Edgewood Dr Ste 104 Lakeland
www.timwagner.org 33803
Tim Murphy 1802 S Parrott Ave
www.timmurphyagency.com 34974
(863) 763-7711

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Highlands County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Erika Tortorici 252 W Van Fleet Dr Ste B
33830
(863) 533-4800

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in Highlands County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Stonybrook Insurance Agency 2151 Us 27 South
33870
Chilton Insurance Agency 1905 Us 27
33870-1858
863-385-3313
The Young Group Of Fuquay 41180 Horseshoe Rd
www.tygof.com 33982
Charles P Faso Inc 223 Us Highway 27 N
www.cfaso.com 33870-2132
863-385-2505

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Highlands County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Key Insurance 309 US HWY 27 S
33852
863-465-7155
Steven L. Strassman 1335 Hwy 17 S
33830
Key Insurance 125 E MAIN ST
33830
863-533-3131
Bruce & Hook Inc 116 S 1st St
33853-4108
863-676-2718
Gates-Cole Assoc 521 E Hickory St
34266
(863) 494-5028
Park Avenue Agency 2 N 1ST ST STE 130
33853
(863) 676-1404
Key Insurance 255 E INTERLAKE BLVD
33852
863-465-7000
Lon Woock 1802 S PARROTT AVE
34974
863-763-7711
Garrett Insurance Agency Inc 143 W Broadway St
www.garrettinsurance.com 33841
(863) 285-7134
Email:info@garrettinsurance.com
Douglas Geyer 240 S 1st St
33853
(863) 676-5658

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Highlands County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Van Fossan & Associates Inc 800 S Parrott Ave
www.vpjinsure.com 34974

Email:chuck@vfainsure.com
William G Hentschel Agcy Inc 250 East Park Avenue
33853
Key Insurance Agency 2 NORTH 1ST ST STE 130
www.keyinsagency.com 33853
863-676-1404
Email:info@KeyInsAgency.com
Key Insurance Agency Inc 146 E STUART AVE
33853
863-676-7691
Key Insurance PO BOX 125
33843
863-635-2201
Simmons First Insurance Services Inc 1105 Us Hwy 27 North
allenkerrinsurance.com 33870
(863) 658-3160
Email:marliese.kerr@simmonsfirst.com
Key City Insurance Agency Inc 2151 US HWY 27 S
www.keycityinsurance.com 33870
863-385-1506
Email:karl@keycityinsurance.com
Fred Buchholz Insurance 240 S Bridge
33975
(863) 675-2411
Email:fredbuchholzinsurance@yahoo.com
Barragan Insurance Agency 6967 Cyprs Gdns Blvd
www.barraganinsurance.com 33884-3572
863-318-8881
Email:INFO@BARRAGANINSURANCE.COM
Dempsey Ins Agency Inc 701 J C Center Ct Unit 11
33954
(941) 613-2112

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Highlands County, FL

TravelersState FarmErie
Median Home Value ($) 89,11079,11089,110
Construction year 201119852011
Home Coverage ($) $75000-$100000$100000-$125000$75000-$100000
Total Premium ($) $1376$1447$840

Highlands County, FL Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Liberty Mutual upto 17%
Erie upto 20%
Allstate upto 16%
Travelers upto 8%