Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Monroe County, FL & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Monroe County, FL

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
Nationwide A+ 8.2%
Erie A+ 7.02%
State Farm A 6.9%
Allstate A+ 4.9%
Travelers A++ 3.1%

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Monroe County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Stephenie Purvine 16782 Sw 88Th St
33196
(305) 400-0619
Mike Grosdidier 4280 Tamiami Trl E Ste 303
www.mikegrosdidier.com 34112
(239) 417-1636
Leroy Holthaus 4280 Tamiami Trl E, Ste 303
34112
Jeff Cline 15441 SW 137 AVE
www.jeffclineagency.com 33177
305-969-8776
Arty Pagan 4400 Thomasson Dr
www.artypagan.com 34112-6767
239-776-7341
Gus Colvin 13802 N Kendall Dr
www.guscolvin.com 33186
(305) 385-6661
Tony Williams 50 Wilson Blvd S #9
34117

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Monroe County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Patty Yaris 583 Tallwood St #102 Marco\u00a0Island
34145
Smith & Eddy Agcy 740 N Collier Blvd Ste 103 Marco\u00a0Island
34145
Thania Salazar 950 N Collier Blvd Marco\u00a0Island
34145
Tracey Bateson 950 N. Collier Blvd 950 N. Collier Blvd Marco\u00a0Island
34145
Carrie-Lee Covington 13755 SW 42nd St
33175-6458
305-551-3335
Eddie Cobayashi 5003 Tamiami Trl E
34113
(239) 774-2624

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Monroe County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Jeff Clark Insurance Agency Llc 15812 SW 137TH AVENUE
33177
305-253-4424
Chance Perry Ins/Fin Serv 15680 N Kendall Dr Ste 200
33196-1160
305-386-7000
The Getzoni Agency Inc 9010 Sw 137 Ave, Ste 208
33186
Ashlee Rebecca Wright Agency 13550 SW 88th St Ste 294
33186-1513
305-385-6696
David B Quintin Inc 255 NE 3rd Drive
33030-4405
305-247-8031
Jeff Clark Insurance Agency Llc 263 NE 8TH ST
33030
305-246-9500

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Monroe County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Amsley Insurance Services Inc 7345 Davis Blvd Ste 7
www.amsleyinsurance.com 34104-5305
239-774-5400
Email:LT@AMSLEYINSURANCE.COM
Hardin Insurance Inc 14453 SW 42nd St
33175
(305) 551-8852
Advantage Insurance Agency Llc 255 NE 3rd Dr
www.advins.org 33030-6154
305-247-8031
Email:tauna@advins.org
Cascade Insurance Agency Llc 1801 N Krome Ave
www.cascadeinsuranceagency.com 33030-3237
305-247-3971
Email:shelli@cascadeinsuranceagency.com
Desando Insurance Services Llc 3825 Beck Blvd Ste 704
34114
(239) 304-9151
Email:info@desandoins.com
Total Insurance Agency Group 1395 Panther Lane St 100
34109
Holman And Company 4979 TAMIAMI TRAIL E
34113
239-403-0097

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in Monroe County, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Springer - Springer Insurance 4735 Santa Barbara Dr Unit 8
34104
Stahlka Agency Inc. 15190 Sw 136Th St Suite 21
www.stahlkaagency.com 33196
(786) 532-1870

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Monroe County, FL

AllstateState FarmErie
Median Home Value ($) 386,100446,100446,100
Construction year 198019722013
Home Coverage ($) $200000-$250000$200000-$250000$175000-$200000
Total Premium ($) $5023$4103$3864

Monroe County, FL Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Allstate upto 21%
Nationwide upto 5%
Travelers upto 11%
Erie upto 19%