Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in North Fort Myers, FL & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in North Fort Myers, FL

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
Nationwide A+ 8.2%
Erie A+ 7.02%
State Farm A 6.9%
Liberty Mutual A 3.2%
Travelers A++ 3.1%

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in North Fort Myers, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
James Lockwood 10915 BONITA BEACH RD STE 1141
34135
239-948-0001
Alyssa Phu 4522 Executive Dr Ste 102
34119-9013
239-594-1717
Thomas Caraceni Lutcf 3900 Cleveland Ave Ft.\u00a0Myers
33901
Jason Seymore 3631 S ACCESS RD
34224
888-254-5014
Lindsay Stifflemire 13 NICHOLAS PKWY W #A
33991
239-458-7468
Crystal Rios 2269 Tamiami Trail S
34293-5067
941-497-4422
Lindsey Lane 1537 BRANTLEY RD BLDG C
33907
239-437-5555
Eliesha Cavanaugh 21202 Olean Blvd Ste E3
33952
(941) 627-9222
Jason Sardi 992 TAMIAMI TRAIL UNIT E2
33953
941-889-7836
Jason Tateishi 100 VENICE AVE W SUITE K
34285
941-483-3999

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in North Fort Myers, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
The Casey Insurance Agency Inc 240 S Bridge St
www.thecaseyagency.net 33935

Email:d.casey@thecaseyagency.net
Insurance Doctor Agency Of Charlottesville 1555 N Tamiami Trl North\u00a0Ft\u00a0Myers
www.myinsurancedoctor.com 33903

Email:mmayberry@myinsurancedoctor.com
Champion Insurance Agency Inc 9541 Cypress Lake Dr
www.champinsurance.com 33919-4947
239-433-2139
Adp Insurance Llc 3509 Lee Blvd Ste 1
33971-1313
239-303-1700
Email:pmaland@adpasiinsurance.com
The Fannin Agency 1412 Dean St Ste 300 Fort\u00a0Myers
www.thefanninagency.com 33901

Email:dfannin@thefanninagency.com
Total Insurance Agency Group 1395 Panther Lane St 100
34109
Ellington Insurance 820 Lafayette St
33904
(239) 471-0600
Hammerstad Insurance Agency Inc 4903 Chiquita Blvd S
33914
(239) 542-1117
Email:mitch@hammerstadins.com
Irving Weber Associates Inc 9180 ESTERO PARK COMMONS BLVD SUITE 9
www.iwains.com 33928
239-992-9711
Email:aweber@iwains.com
The Fessler Agency Inc 236 Pedro St
www.fessleragency.com 34285

Email:commercial@fessleragency.com

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in North Fort Myers, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
The Tillman Agency 1104 Se 46Th Lane #4 Cape\u00a0Coral
33904
Michael P Manci Agency 9390 Dynasty Drive Suite 105
33905
1-239-277-5122
Daughtry Ins Agency Inc 702 Leeland Heights Blvd W
33936-6620
239-369-0545
Teddy J Byrd Agency 555 E Ave
34285
Holly Mcmillin Agency 6609 WILLOW PARK DR STE 201
34109
239-261-6116
Ds Sherwood & Assoc Ins & Fin Svcs 2425 Tamiami Trl N Ste 212
34103
(239) 261-6533
Brenda E. Hurley 1199 N Sumter Blvd
34286-8074
941-429-7955
Denise Sullivan Clement Agency 1807 Englewood Rd
34223
(941) 475-7778
Holly Mcmillin Agency 2061 TRADE CENTER WAY
34109
239-591-4028
Dennis Charles Oneill 21554 Angela Ln
34293
(941) 493-5808

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in North Fort Myers, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
The Young Group Of Fuquay 41180 Horseshoe Rd
www.tygof.com 33982
Lindquist Insurance Associates Inc. 1103 CAPE CORAL PKWY EAST SUITE A
33904
239-549-6255
Partners Hometown Insurance Agency Llc 889 111TH AVE N STE 201
34108
(239) 261-0428
Brockey Insurance Agency 12995 S Clevlnd Ave Ste 103B
www.brockeyinsurance.com 33907-3859
239-561-8599
Strachan Insurance Agency Inc. 421 A Commercial Court
34292
Spathies Insurance Agency Inc. 12660 World Plaza Ln Ft.\u00a0Myers
33907
Short Pump Insurance Llc 230 Tamiami Trl S Ste 31
34285
Anderson-Williamson Ins Llc 3765 Airport Rd N Ste 100
34105-4517
239-261-8287
The Wes Connor Agency 728 Sw Pine Island Rd #16 Cape\u00a0Coral
www.wesconnor.com 33991
(239) 800-9869
Springer - Springer Insurance 4735 Santa Barbara Dr Unit 8
34104

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in North Fort Myers, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Taylor Wisowaty 1617 Santa Barbara Blvd Ste 1 Cape\u00a0Coral
www.taylorinsures.com 33991
(239) 829-4898
Zach Hadley 900 5Th Avenue South Ste. 201
www.zachhadleyinsurance.com 34102
Denise Wegner 340 Tamiami Trl S Ste 101
www.denisewegner.com 34275
(941) 484-8884
Rob Shirley 2017 Tamiami Trail S Unit B
34293
(941) 244-4082
Lindsay Mullen 7800 UNIVERSITY POINTE DR 100
www.lindsaymullen.com 33907
800-327-0977
Mike Grosdidier 4280 Tamiami Trl E Ste 303
www.mikegrosdidier.com 34112
(239) 417-1636
Michael D Nichols 109 E Olympia Ave Punta\u00a0Gorda
33950
Wendi Thomas 6702 Lone Oak Blvd
www.wendithomas.biz 34109
Jim Stoltz 309 U S Hwy 27 S
33852
Sharon Wilson 13720-2 Ben C. Pratt/6 Mile Cypress Pkwy
33912

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in North Fort Myers, FL

State FarmNationwideTravelers
Median Home Value ($) 84,07084,07084,070
Construction year 201019901989
Home Coverage ($) $75000-$100000$125000-$150000$125000-$150000
Total Premium ($) $1724$2637$1939

North Fort Myers, FL Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Liberty Mutual upto 18%
Travelers upto 11%
Nationwide upto 7%
Erie upto 18%